Sponsor

Pioneer Connect Premium Wi-Fi Mobile Phone Home Business Lincoln County Oregon Coast Pioneer Connect Premium Wi-Fi Mobile Phone Home Business Lincoln County Oregon Coast Pioneer Connect Premium Wi-Fi Mobile Phone Home Business Lincoln County Oregon Coast
Donate

Independent, non-profit news • Established 2019

  • Home
  • About
  • Sections
    • Community News
    • News Briefs
    • Oregon/NW News
    • Oregon Coast Today
    • Obituaries
    • Letters
    • Police/Fire News
    • A Picture Tells the Story
    • 5 Questions and a Secret
  • Events
    • Events Calendar
    • Civic Meetings Calendar
    • Sports Calendar and Results
  • Weather/Tides
    • Weather Forecast
    • WeatherLink
    • Weather Underground
    • Yachats tides
    • Waldport Tides
  • Contact
    • Sign Up
    • Guidelines for letters
    • How to submit obituaries
    • Submit a News Release
    • Submit a Photo
  • Advertise
  • Public Notices
Oregon News

Federal agency’s proposal to kill a half-million barred owls in Northwest sparks controversy

April 8, 2024
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Bluesky
  • Linkedin
  • Email

    By CLARE MARIE SCHNEIDER/National Public Radio

    A proposal by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to kill roughly half a million barred owls to protect the spotted owl has conservationists and animal welfare advocates debating the moral issue of killing one species to protect another.

    The proposal, published in November, garnered attention recently after dozens of wildlife protection and animal welfare organizations signed a letter opposing the plan.

    In a March 25 letter responding to the proposal, a group of 75 organizations urged Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland, to scrap what it calls a “reckless” plan. “Non-lethal management actions to protect spotted owls and their habitats should be made the priority action,” it read.

    But the USFWS says if no action is taken to cull the barred owl population, the northern spotted owl faces extinction.

    The barred owl is crowding out its less aggressive relative, the northern spotted owl, in the Northwestern states, according to the USFWS. To ensure the survival of the northern spotted owl, a threatened species, the service is proposing the mass removal of over 470,000 barred owls across California, Washington and Oregon over a three-decade span. The proposed action will also help prevent declines in the California spotted owls, another species facing competition from barred owls, it said.

    Wayne Pacelle, president of the Center for a Human Economy and its lobbying arm, Animal Wellness Action, who co-authored the letter, called the plan “unworkable.” He says it’s doubtful that the government’s plan can be successfully executed across such a long time frame.

    “If you don’t do it dutifully and religiously every single year for 30 years, it has no chance of succeeding,” Pacelle told NPR.

    He argues that lethal management programs often succeed on closed ecosystems such as islands, but a management plan covering such a vast region wouldn’t be as effective.

    Cameron Barrows, a retired emeritus researcher at the Center for Conservation Biology at the University of California-Riverside, says that without a barred owl management strategy, spotted owls will disappear.

    “If nothing is done to slow the encroachment of barred owls, you will lose spotted owls,” he said. “There aren’t a lot of choices left.”

    To him, the letter opposing the proposal effectively “means ‘We’d rather have barred owls than spotted owls,’ ” he said.

    A conservation organization in Washington also supports the proposed action. Birds Connect Seattle published a letter in January citing “preventing extinction” as one of its priorities.

    “We are not celebrating this management plan in issuing our support,” said Claire Catania, the executive director of Birds Connect Seattle. But, she says, her organization recognizes its necessity.

    A human-created problem

    Conservation experts who support the proposal say it’s a difficult but necessary plan that will help solve a problem that humans helped create.

    In 1990, the northern spotted owl was listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act after environmentalists fought to protect the bird’s habitat from the logging industry. The threatened designation also means the Fish and Wildlife Service is legally required to protect the northern spotted owl.

    But around the same time, the barred owl, originally native to the Eastern U.S., emerged as another threat as it moved West, encroaching on spotted owl territory. Human-driven habitat destruction spurred the barred owls to expand across the country, Catania says. Their move west has since displaced their “smaller, less aggressive cousins,” the spotted owl, according to Cornell Lab of Ornithology.

    The spotted owl’s habitat — old-growth forests — has become “very patchy” due to deforestation and are accessible to the more adaptable barred owl, says Barrows, the UC Riverside conservation researcher.

    “This is a problem that humans have created. This wasn’t nature happening on its own,” Barrows said.

    The Fish and Wildlife Service’s proposal, outlined in a draft report assessing its environmental impact, is the latest attempt in a more than two-decade effort to save the spotted owl from extinction. A decade ago, the FWS began a four-year experiment to kill up to 3,600 barred owls in the northwest. According to Barrows, this strategy “slowed down but didn’t stop” the barred owl invasion.

    The public comment period for the proposal closed in January. A final proposal is expected in this spring or summer, NBC News reported.

    Copyright 2024 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

    4 Comments Leave a Reply

    1. Renee says:
      April 10, 2024 at 6:02 am

      Genocide of one species to “protect” another while we continue to ravage the habitat required to support said species seems asinine. If we are truly going to take a stand that one species can be more important than another species. We need to consider how many mass extinctions humans are responsible for and should we consider similar measures to protect species by managing the numbers of humans that are destroying/out-competing others?

    2. Shelly says:
      April 10, 2024 at 9:16 am

      When will humans learn that this method of “wildlife management” is not a successful tool. Consider how unsuccessful the culling of those cormorants was or the killing of sea lions at Bonneville Dam. This methodology has a long history of unsuccessful results including extermination and extirpation of wolves, coyotes and other species by man in attempts to rearrange nature to man’s vision of how it should be. Time for a new paradigm.

    3. Philip Spulnik says:
      April 10, 2024 at 11:48 am

      The USFWS cannot be trusted anymore. In the 1990’s 95% of all timber harvest was curtained and 20 years later, no increase in the spotted owl. The results ruined a whole industry. Now some self-proclaimed scientist says the spotted owl will become extinct if all the barred owls are not killed off. This is total baloney. After spending seven years of my life studying wildlife science and fisheries at Oregon State, I can tell you these people don’t know, period. Populations studies will tell you that in a predator-prey relationship that if the prey gets to a low enough level the predator species will decrease in population size. They are messing around with Mother Nature. The spotted owl is a cute little stupid bird. It will land on you hand if you hold a mouse in it. Let Mother Nature take its course.

      • Judy Pelletier says:
        April 11, 2024 at 1:46 pm

        Darn right Phil; plus, inhibiting timber harvesting and deactivation of logging roads and forest access have increased “down and dead” trees and brush, creating perfect conditions for devastating forest fires that we have experienced recently.

    Comments are closed.

    Pioneer Connect Premium Wi-Fi Mobile Phone Home Business Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    ACE Hardware Walport Oregon Coast
    Lincoln City Local Government Working for You We Want Your Feedback Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    Oregon State University Hatfield Marine Science Visitor Center Newport Oregon
    Sweet homes vacation rentals Help Wanted Oregon coast
    AARP Foundation Tax-Aide Volunteers Join our team Lincoln County Newport Oregon
    David Gomberg State Representative Oregon
    Samaritan House Family Shelter Dancing with the Coastal Stars Newport Performing Arts Center Newport Oregon Coast
    Tanner Insurance Devoted Health Plans Medicare Advantage Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    Yachats Lions Club Thrift Store Yachats Oregon Coast
    Literary Arts Timothy Snyder Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall Portland Oregon
    Yachats Chamber of Commerce Visit Yachats Oregon Coast
    Charlotte Lehto Insurance Agency Farmer's Insurance Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    Newport Farmers Market Newport Oregon Coast
    Dahl Disposal Better Bark and More Waldport Oregon Coast
    Lincoln City Cultural Center Turkish Rugs Show and Sale Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    Waldport Chamber of Commerce Memberships Lincoln County Oregon Coast
    Oregon Coast Aquarium Puffin Plate Newport Oregon
    Samaritan Health Services Samaritan Orthopedics Program Lincoln County Oregon Coast

    Letters from readers

    Look at Medicare Advantage plans carefully before making a decision

    Lincoln County has benefitted from Hall’s service for 20 years

    Jacobi urges voters to not sign Hall recall petition

    More letters


    Obituaries

    Marie Jones of Newport

    Rebecca L. Bloch of Yachats

    Sandra Lee Dunn of Yachats

    More obituaries

    Civic Calendar

    Oct 20
    4:00 pm - 7:00 pm

    Newport City Council work session and regular meeting

    Oct 21
    10:00 am

    Southwest Lincoln Water People’s Utility District board

    Oct 21
    2:00 pm - 4:00 pm

    Yachats Planning Commission monthly workshop and meeting

    Oct 27
    6:00 pm - 8:00 pm

    Newport Planning Commission work session and regular meeting

    Nov 4
    2:00 pm - 4:00 pm

    City of Yachats Parks & Commons Commission

    Nov 6
    7:00 pm - 9:00 pm

    Yachats Big Band monthly concert

    Nov 10
    10:30 am - 12:00 pm

    Yachats Rural Fire Protection District board

    Nov 11
    10:00 am - 11:30 pm

    Yachats Planning Commission monthly workshop meeting

    Nov 11
    2:00 pm - 3:30 pm

    Yachats Public Works & Streets Commission

    Nov 11
    5:00 pm - 8:00 pm

    Lincoln County School District board of directors

    View Calendar

    © 2025 Lincoln Chronicle. All rights reserved.

    • Home
    • About
    • Sections
      • Community News
      • News Briefs
      • Oregon/NW News
      • Oregon Coast Today
      • Obituaries
      • Letters
      • Police/Fire News
      • A Picture Tells the Story
      • 5 Questions and a Secret
    • Events
      • Events Calendar
      • Civic Meetings Calendar
      • Sports Calendar and Results
    • Weather/Tides
      • Weather Forecast
      • WeatherLink
      • Weather Underground
      • Yachats tides
      • Waldport Tides
    • Contact
      • Sign Up
      • Guidelines for letters
      • How to submit obituaries
      • Submit a News Release
      • Submit a Photo
    • Advertise
    • Public Notices